“ולגדלתו אין חקר”- The Human Mind is not Capable of Understanding G-dliness
Details: English 26 min
Listen
A version with the sound improved by AI is also available · Listen to it
About this shiur
The Mashgiach explains why chakirah, philosophy, is a dangerous and unreliable path to emunah: the human mind is not the organ that grasps Hashem, while the neshamah, a part of G-d above, can feel Him unless aveiros insulate it.
After reviewing two approaches to emunah, inherited faith and seeing Hashem's wonders, the Mashgiach turns to a third, chakirah or philosophy. He notes that yeshivos learn the Rambam's halachos but not his Moreh Nevuchim, and explains why: philosophy is mental acrobatics, and a sharper mind can always refute a proof. Jewish philosophy arose in Arab lands to keep Jews from Greek thought, but the Gedolei Yisrael rejected it, and the Mashgiach tells how Rabbeinu Yonah, after Gemaras were burned in Paris, did teshuvah for his part in burning the Rambam's sefer. The mind, made of flesh, cannot grasp the Creator, as a watch cannot understand the watchmaker; the organ for that is the neshamah and nevuah, which aveiros insulate. Philosophy exposes a person to the kasha without the teretz. He closes with the Spanish expulsion, where simple Jews gave their lives while the philosophers converted.
Topics: Simple Emunah, Above Reason · Doubts in Emunah and Amalek