האומות מכירים וכופרים מטעם של rationalization
Details: Yiddish 28 min
Listen
A version with the sound improved by AI is also available · Listen to it
About this shiur
The Mashgiach explains from the Rambam that our belief in the Torah rests on the mesorah of Har Sinai, so no later prophet can change it, and that the nations, who know this, deny it through rationalization born of jealousy.
The Mashgiach recalls that the mesorah of Klal Yisroel is true because a whole nation heard Hashem at Har Sinai, and that a prophet is believed only because the Torah commands it, like two witnesses. With the Rambam in Hilchos Yesodei HaTorah he shows that a prophet with signs who contradicts Moshe is not heeded, as witnesses who say it is night are not believed by one who sees daylight. The Torah cannot be added to or changed, so the claims of the nations about a new law collapse; Bilaam himself said Hashem does not change His mind. Why do they hold on? Rationalization and jealousy of the chosen people. The Mashgiach applies this to Rashi's question about the first mitzvah, to Moshe as father of all prophets, and to the world's preoccupation with Jews and Yerushalayim. A story of a dying heretic who recanted shows that rationalization falls away at the end. He closes that mesorah is the halachic basis of emunah.
Topics: Torah Min HaShamayim and the Mesorah · Yisroel and the Nations