בינוני - זה וזה שופטן וה' מכריע. תשובה על הקושיא על המילים - תהא בעיניך כרשע.
Details: Perek י"ב Yiddish 39 min
Listen
A version with the sound improved by AI is also available · Listen to it
About this shiur
The Mashgiach explains why the beinoni is judged by two 'judges', the good and evil inclinations, with Hashem as the deciding voice, and how this answers why even a tzaddik should regard himself as a rasha.
Finishing Tanya chapter 12, the Mashgiach explains that the beinoni cannot stop thoughts of envy, hatred or resentment from arising, but has the choice not to accept them. Emunah that everything comes from Hashem removes resentment, as David said of Shimi ben Gera and as Yosef repaid his brothers with good; a tzaddik told a shopkeeper to thank Hashem for every customer who went to his competitor. Moving to chapter 13, he explains the Gemara's 'zeh v'zeh shoftan': the yetzer hara is a judge giving an opinion, not a ruler, and Hashem is the decider who helps the good side. The world is balanced between good and evil, but the Creator stands above it, as light drives out darkness. Hashem helps only one who struggles himself. This answers 'be in your eyes like a rasha': without Hashem's help the yetzer would win. Finally, the beinoni's evil is only asleep during prayer, which explains Rabbah's error in calling himself a beinoni.
Topics: Tzaddik, Beinoni and Rasha (Tanya ch. 9-17) · The Yetzer Hara and Nisyonos