Rabbi Akiva and Ben Koziva

About: Rabbi Akiva Bar Kochba (Ben Koziva) the Rambam Rabbi Yochanan ben Torta

The story

Retold here from 6 tellings; details differ from one to another. Hear it in the shiur.

Ben Koziva was a powerful king and a tzaddik who ruled from the city of Beitar, had an army and went to war against the Romans. Rabbi Akiva, the greatest of the Tanna'im, was his right-hand man and announced that he was Moshiach. The Romans captured and destroyed Beitar and Ben Koziva was killed, and then it became known that he was not Moshiach. He had performed no miracles. Rabbi Yochanan ben Torta told Rabbi Akiva at the time that grass would grow on his cheeks and Moshiach would still not have come. In some tellings the Mashgiach adds that because Rabbi Yochanan ben Torta had said so beforehand, the Jews were spared a crisis of faith when Ben Koziva fell.

Where he tells it

In order of year where it is known; the undated ones last.

The shiurim in which the story is told
Shiur Occasion Year Language At
Purim Seudah פורים תשנ"א (1990–91) Yiddish 1:24:47
The Current פרשיות Allude to the גמר החתימה (Explanation of the Concept of פקידה) אלול תשנ"ט (1998–99) English 50:02
Purim Hameshusash פורים המשולש תשס"ה (2004–05) Yiddish 39:14
Purim Seudah פורים תשע"ב (2011–12) Yiddish 2:48:18
Purim Seudah פורים תשע"ו (2015–16) Yiddish 2:22:57
Exterminating Parasites of Emunah The Halachos of Believing in Mashiach EMUNAH #2 The Seven Wonders of Judaism: A series of Lectures that enrich the Emunah Series #1. not known English 23:28